Fireworks Safety Tips and the Fourth of July

We hope that you have a Happy and safe Fourth of July this year. 

In an effort to promote Consumer Safety we would like to share a few important facts and safety tips for handling Fireworks from the CPSC:

  •  Read and follow all warnings and instructions
     
  •  Never allow children to play with or ignite fireworks
     
  •  Keep other people are out of range before lighting fireworks.
     
  •  Only light fireworks on a smooth, flat surface away from the house, dry leaves, and  flammable materials.
     
  •  Never try to relight fireworks that have not fully functioned.
     
  •  Keep a bucket of water in case of a malfunction or fire.

The National Fire Protection Association cites the following statistics:

In 2008, across the country 7,000 people were treated for fireworks-related injuries. 40 percent of the injuries involved kids.
Over half of the injuries were burns to the arms, legs and hands.
One out of five of the injuries nvolved hot debris hitting people's eyes.

Palm Beach County, Deputy Fire Marshall, Jeff Collins sums it up perfectly in a recent interview with the Sun Sentinel:

"Your best bet is to let the professionals handle the fireworks". 

Last year, Managing Partner, Brian LaBovick, wrote a wonderful post on How to Avoid Injuries with Fireworks and  the importance of the Fourth of July.  Enjoy reading the post.

Have a Happy and Safe Fourth of July.

Videotaping and Trial Preparation - Can it help the Client's testimony?

I came across a post by Blogger Barry Barnett for the legal blog, Blawgletter today.  The post was  entitled Video and Witness Prep. Mr. Barnett shared his views on videotaping and trial preparation for a client. In this post, he shared that if you do not adequately prepare a client with crucial foundation, don't bother with the video. 

In an effort to see how a few Personal Injury Attorneys in our law firm viewed witness videotaping, I shared Mr. Barnett's post and the post from Deliberations,  entitled "Why your witness did not get better after watching herself on videotape"., and asked for feedback.

I found the comments from my Attorneys insightful and decided to share a few thoughts on the subject from Brian F. LaBovick and Mark A. Greenberg.

Managing Partner, Brian F. LaBovick, provided the the following comments on the subject:

"We all understand ourselves!  How many times have you gotten into a fight with your loved one where you said one thing and they heard another?  I am sure the answer is plenty.  It is the same reason why witnesses who view themselves on video don't get better. We can't judge ourselves because we understand what we said in the first place.  

In our firm, we believe training witnesses needs objective help. Objective help can't be the lawyer or his/her paralegal training the client.  Objective evidence can be a paid expert; someone who can teach the client how to improve. Objective analysis can include watching yourself on video while at the same time watching mock juror's response to the client. Observing jurors reactions, and or polling them to discuss what they felt during the testimony is the best. It hurts to hear sometimes, but the juror's "truth" is all that counts at trial. It is better to be prepared now, than to be blindsided when the final Verdict is read in court!"
Attorney Mark A. Greenberg added the following comments on the subject of videotaping client testimony for trial preparation:

"As humans, we tend to emphasize our strengths and ignore our weaknesses. We think our kids are great at everything, even if it is not true. Sometimes, the same holds true for our clients. 

When preparing a client for trial, simply showing them a videotape of their testimony may not help correct deficiencies in demeanor, body language, or argumentative behavior. Instead, examine the entire picture. Focus on what they do well, and show them later exactly what parts could be improved and explain why. Give examples. Tape their testimony as it improves (hopefully) so they can see the difference. In the end, a client’s testimony is the most critical part of the trial. Taking the time to get it right, rather than just critiquing a video tape can help lead to a just verdict. "

If you are involved in a Personal Injury case or another type of case that is headed to trial, make sure that you discuss videotaping as an option with yourAttorney.  If you are an Attorney, be honest with your clients and share constructive criticism.  As Brian mentioned, "sometimes the truth hurts". It is best to be prepared. 

From The Courtroom Podcast - Brian LaBovick

LaBovick & LaBovick, P.A.  is pleased to launch the new Podcast series "From the Courtroom".  The new Podcast  "From the Courtroom" will discuss legal topics and community issues. The shows will be taped in the LaBovick & LaBovick Mock Trial Courtroom, located in the Palm Gardens Headquarters. The shows will feature attorneys from the firm and will periodically interview guests on the show that are community leaders.  

The first edition of "From the Courtroom" features Brian F. LaBovick, Esq., Managing Partner.

Listeners are encouraged to tune in weekly to check out the various  topics discussed on the LaBovick & LaBovick law blogs:

LaBovick Injury Law Blog
Whistleblower Law Blog
The Law Planet Blog

Please feel free to drop us a line if you want to hear any specific topics discussed on "From the Courtroom" Podcast.

 

injurylaw.labovick.com/uploads/file/Podcast 04102009-Brian-First_mp3_final_rev.mp3

Economic loss and valuation of a Claim

Have you ever noticed that sometimes things in life are unfair? In the legal world that adage also holds true. Take for example: If an unmarried adult, without minor children (say a grandmother whose children are grown and whose husband passed away) goes to see a doctor and that doctor accidentally kills her due to obvious and total malpractice there is no way to bring a malpractice suit. The adult children do not have the right to bring that suit on behalf of their dead mother. That seems unfair to me.

Another example,  is pets. Dogs, cats, etc.., have no value beyond their replacement value. In other words, if I have a fantastic dog who is my kids best friend and a great part of our family and someone kills that dog, I can only recover the value to replace that dog. If that dog was a mutt from the dog-pound, then the replacement cost is about $60.00. The emotional loss is terrible for the family, but the economic loss small.

What would you do if you took your photos to a photo lab for development and they lost your photos or even destroyed them? There is a value to those photos. The emotional value is very large, but the economic value is small. Although you have the right to recover for any loss, you are likely restricted to the economic loss. That economic loss is so small that is isn't worth the fight. I do not believe Florida law has changed to allow emotional losses in commercial cases. There is a legal rule called the Economic Loss Rule that prohibits emotional damages in commercial cases. I have not researched the Economic Loss Rule for some time, but I do not believe it has changed. Recently I saw a legal article advocating the law permit emotional losses in some situations: Movers who destroy family heirlooms that are worthless but have great family value was the example given *(which is similar  to lost photos). I do not believe, however, the present state of the law permits such recovery.
 

Roy C. Young wrote an interesting article on economic loss called “Florida Supreme Court Overturns the "Economic Loss Rule". In the article, he shares the following sentiments:
That Florida recognizes the responsibility of individual professionals for their negligent acts is also evidenced by the express provisions of two legislative enactments that are relevant here–section 471.023, Florida Statutes (1993), pertaining to engineers, and section 621.07, Florida Statutes (1993), pertaining to professional associations. Both of these statutory provisions permit professionals to practice in the form of a corporation or partnership for the purpose of rendering professional services. However, both sections indicate an intent to hold professionals personally liable for their negligent acts by expressly stating that the formation of a corporation or partnership shall not relieve the individual members of their personal professional liability.

Section 621.07 of the Professional Service Corporation Act ("Act"), states in pertinent part:
Nothing contained in this act shall be interpreted to abolish, repeal, modify, restrict, or limit the law now in effect in this state applicable to the professional relationship and liabilities between the person furnishing the professional services and the person receiving such professional service and to the standards for professional conduct; provided, however, that any officer, agent, member, manager, or employee of a corporation or limited liability company organized under this act shall be personally liable and accountable only for negligent or wrongful acts or misconduct committed by that person, or by any person under that person's direct supervision and control, while rendering professional service on behalf of the corporation or limited liability company to the person for whom such professional services were being rendered . . . .

§ 621.07, Fla. Stat. (1997). Similarly, section 471.023(3) expressly applies to engineers and states in pertinent part: (3) The fact that a registered engineer practices through a corporation or partnership shall not relieve the registrant from personal liability for negligence, misconduct, or wrongful acts committed by him. . . . Any officer, agent, or employee of a corporation shall be personally liable and accountable only for negligent acts, wrongful acts, or misconduct committed by him or committed by any person under his direct supervision and control, while rendering professional services on behalf of the corporation.
After reading this excerpt, one may ask the question: does this mean that person is or is not responsible?

First, I must point out that this is one of those interesting niche areas of the law. The Economic Loss Rule was supposed to stop lawsuits for pain and suffering damages in contract cases. In other words, it was intended to limit damages to the economic effect of the contract so people wouldn't be suing for their inconvenience damages, their pain and suffering damages etc, when one party breaches a contract.

There are, however, many exceptions that the rule so the rule is a fuzzy line, not a bright line. The Supreme Court case Phillipe H/ Moransais, vs. Paul S. Heathman, an individual, Bromwell & Carrier, Inc, a Florida corporation, Lennon D. Jordan and J/ Larry Sauls is a fuzzy case which is an exception to the economic loss rule. Another fuzzy area is professional malpractice. Any time you are dealing with professional services and those services are done negligently there is an issue as to whether the Economic Rule applies.

I hope that this explains economic loss and how important it is when an attorney or an insurance company values a case.
 

Brian.

Join LaBovick & LaBovick helping the uninsured at a Back to School Florida KidCare enrollment fair

LaBovick & LaBovick, PA invites you to attend the Back to School Florida Kidcare enrollment Fair in West Palm Beach on August 3, 2008 from 12 noon - 3pm. The location is  2601 Military Trail (Corner of Crest Haven Blvd & Military Trail) West Palm Beach, at  the Shoppes of Cresthaven.

This event is being put on through the efforts of Palm Beach County Coalition members:  Kid Finders Network, Childrens Services Council of Palm Beach, Health Care District of Palm Beach County, Stay Well, Florida Department of Children and Family, Healthy Mothers and Healthy Babies, Procer Cultural Organization, Florida Covering Kids & Families, LaBovick & LaBovick, PA and many others.

The Health Care crisis in Florida is serious with over 700,000 children without Healthcare coverage, yet  many are eligible to receive Florida KidCare insurance, either by a low cost or free option.

"The purpose of the Back to School Florida KidCare Enrollment Fair is to bring awareness of the healthcare coverage available to kids in Florida without health insurance coverage", stated, Attorney Esther Uria LaBovick, Partner, LaBovick & LaBovick, PA.

Coalition Member, Kid Finders Network will provide digital fingerprints to  kids enrolling in Florida KidCare. KidFinders Network will also be give out professional Kits for Child ID cards at the Florida KidCare Back to School Enrollment Fair.

The main thing is that Free School Supplies will be given to Kids attending the event.  There will be food, Entertainment and fun giveaways for  families and kids attending the Back to School Enrollment Fair.

Please Share this information with any family that has children and cannot afford to provide healthcare coverage for their kids.

Palm Beach County Florida KidCare - Back to School - Enrollment Fair Sunday, August 3, 2008 -

 12 noon - 3pm - Admission is Free
 

Earth Day - April 22, 2008 - we can all do something

Today, April 22, 2008 is Earth Day. It is amazing that Earth Day has been around since 1970 and I only seem to remember hearing about it a few years ago.  Last week I purchased several reusable shopping bags at Publix, a major chain in the Southeast. Initially, I thought the .99 price tag was just a gimmick to get people to buy a product.  I see that I was wrong, as I bring my 4 bags back to the market with me, I am pleasantly surprised to see other shoppers doing the same.  The bags are awesome. One bag takes the place of 4 plastic shopping bags and two large paper bags. Based on my bagging methods. 

I spoke to Managing Partner, Brian LaBovick, Esq. regarding my post on Earth Day and asked what he was doing today to acknowledge Earth Day. After my story of the Publix "reusable shopping bags" he decided to go out and buy bags for all of our LaBovick & LaBovick staff members in an effort to help promote saving the environment in small steps. Yes, I mention small steps, because if we all take a few steps to make the environment better, it will make a difference. According to the EPA, companies can make a difference at the work place in helping the environment. A few   simple things, to start with include: 1) reducing energy use, 2) Re-use or recycle office products, 3) Use water more efficiently 4) Efficient Commuting for the environment, this includes, working from home when possible, carpooling use of mass transportation 5) Turn off  equipment, copier, printers, computers when not in use, 6) Use energy efficient lighting.

As a Boutique Florida Personal Injury Law firm, we are doing a little bit more than just giving reusable Publix Shopping bags to our employees. About a year ago, Managing Partner, Brian LaBovick, told me that he wanted to go paperless. He asked me to investigate and find the necessary steps on what it will take for us to be a paperless office. Imagine a paperless law firm. Believe it or not, they do exist. They are few and far between, but not impossible.

We are exploring the paperless office, which will take some time and effort, but in the interim, our Florida Injury Law Firm has taken some giant leaps in being more efficient and environmentally friendly. Last year we recycled old computers and monitors, after stripping them of all data, first. We shred and recycle paper and recycle cans that we use for beverages in the firm for staff and clients. We purchased a state of the art copier to scan documents for us to send PDFs of files to Doctors,  Insurance Adjusters, Defense Counsel, Experts and others involved in Personal injury and Qui tam cases we are working on. This cuts down on the use of paper tremendously. We satisfy requests of those that prefer receiving paper instead of a PDF or file.

If our Florida Injury Law firm can take small steps in our business to help the environment, we encourage other firms to join in.  A few weeks ago, the wonderful Governor of Florida, attended a "Going Green" event in Palm Beach County sponsored by Palm Tran. It is nice to see that officials in Florida are trying to make the public aware of their efforts to improve the environment.

You too can make a difference and do your part for our environment.

About

At LaBovick & LaBovick, P.A. we have a reputation for fighting for justice, with relentless perserverance. We handle cases involving brain injuries, car accidents, dog bites, truck accidents, wrongful death, medical malpractice, products liability and false claims act/ qui tam claims. Our attorneys work to make sure that our clients receive justice. We do not defend insurance companies.

Attorneys of the Firm

Brian F. LaBovick, Esq. is Managing Partner of the Firm. He earned a Bachelors of Arts in Philosophy at Miami University in Oxford, Ohio in 1987. He obtained a Juris Doctor at the University of Miami School of Law in Miami, Florida in 1990. Brian LaBovick was admitted to the Florida and Federal Bars in 1990. He began his legal career in the prestigious Honors Graduate Program at the United States Department of Justice as a prosecutor in 1990. He has extensive trial and litigation experience. He concentrates his practice on prosecuting plaintiff personal injury, product liability, premises liability, toxic torts, and whistleblower/qui-tam claims. Brian LaBovick maintains an AV rating with Martindale-Hubbell and is listed in the Register of Pre-eminent Lawyers. He is past President of the NPBC Bar Association, past Director of Palm Beach County Justice Association; an Eagle Member of the Florida Justice Association, a member of the American Association for Justice; a Task Force Member of Florida Justice Association PAC; a CLE Committee Member for the Florida Justice Association, a Member of the Academy of Trial Advocates and the National Belli Society. He actively gives back to the Community and is involved in the American Cancer Society, Board Member of the Benjamin School, the Quantum House, the Papanicolaou Corps for Cancer Research, the Jupiter Tequesta Athletic Association, the Jewish Federation and Board Member of Temple Betham.

Esther Uria LaBovick, Esq. earned a Bachelors of Arts from Duke University in Durham, North Carolina in 1987. She earned a Juris Doctor from University of Miami School of Law in 1990. She was admitted to the Florida State and Federal Bars in 1990. She served as Assistant State Attorney for the Dade County State Attorneys Office, under Janet Reno. She was trained as a part of a special DUI prosecution unit in Dade County. esther LaBovick has extensive trial experience in prosecuting complex litigation cases. Her practice areas include product liability, personal injury, toxic torts, and consumer claims. She is a member of the Palm Beach Trial Lawyers Association, the American Bar Association, and the Florida Justice Association and the American Association of Justice. Esther.. LaBovick is active in the community and champions the causes of several organizations, such as the Quantum House, The South Florida Science Museum, The Benjamin School, The Latin American Cultural Center, and The Junior League of The Palm Beaches. She is Chair of the Worth Tasting Cookbook Committee for the Junior League and serves as President Elect of the Junior League of The Palm Beaches.

Carl J. Wald, Esq. earned a Bachelors of Science from Buffalo State College in 1989. He earned a Juris Doctor from Thomas M. Cooley Law School in Lansing, Michigan. He was admitted to the Florida Bar in 1996. He has earned a pilots license and clocks several miles in the air flying single and twin engine planes. Mr. Wald has extensive trial experience and was inducted into the Million Dollar Advocates Forum for his success in winning jury verdicts in excess of a million dollars. He actively gives back to the community and is involved in the Palm Beach Trial Lawyers Association, the American Bar Association, the Florida Justice Association and the American Association of Justice as an Eagle Member. In addition to his passion for flying planes, he enjoys playing Rugby with the Palm Beach Rugby Team.

Mark R. Hanson, Esq. is Director of the Litigation Division and is admitted to the Florida Bar. He earned a Bachelor's Degree from University of San Diego. He earned his law degree from Tulane University Law School. For over 20 years, Mr. Hanson has dedicated his legal career to fighting for the rights of injury accident victims and commercial litigation. Over the years, he has received many distinctions and honors. He is AV Rated, by Martindale Hubbell. He is a member of the prestigious Million Dollar Advocates Forum. He was named to Florida Trend Magazine's Florida Legal Elite and is one of seven attorneys statewide recognized in the Aviation, Admiralty & Maritime category. In addition, he was named a Florida Super Lawyer, by Super Lawyers Magazine; only 5% of all lawyers in Florida are named Florida Super Lawyers. Mr. Hanson concentrates his practice in the areas of Maritime/Admiralty Law, Personal Injury, Products Liability, Toxic Torts and Commercial Litigation.

Bobbie Celler, Esq. is the Director of the the PIP Suit Litigation Division and is admitted to the Florida Bar. He earned a Bachelor's of Science in Criminology and Political Science from The University of Tampa. He earned a Juris Doctor from Nova Southeastern University Shepard Broad Law Center. Mr. Celler is a licensed Attorney in the State of Florida. He is an aggressive and experienced trial attorney in Personal Injury and PIP Suit Litigation. Prior to joining the firm, Mr. Celler was an accomplished Commercial Realtor. He represented local, regional and national companies for their retail, office, industrial and investment needs. He handled large multi-million dollar transactions with national companies to office and retail leasing for independently owned businesses. Mr. Celler concentrates his practice in the area of PIP Suit Litigation.

Scott R. Haft Esq. is admitted to the Florida Bar. He earned a Bachelor's of Arts in Business Administration, from Franklin & Marshall College, Lancaster, Pennsylvania. He earned his law degree from Nova Southeastern University - Shepard Broad Law Center, Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Mr. Haft had the distinct honor of serving as a Legal Intern for the U.S. Attorney's Office, Southern District of Florida for two years. He is a talented and aggressive attorney. Mr. Haft concentrates his practice in the following areas: Employment Law, Commerical Litigation, Securities Fraud, Mortgage Foreclosure Defense, and Qui tam.

Michael B. Steinbaum, Esq.  is admitted to the Florida Bar. He earned a Bachelors degree in Finance from Florida State University, Tallahassee, Florida. He earned his law degree from Nova Southeastern University Shepard Broad Law Center in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Mr. Steinbaum has prosecuted and assisted in the prosecution of such public violations as city minimum property standards, the preparation of and defense of ordinances, contracts, franchise agreements, and leases. Mr. Steinbaum had the distinct honor of serving as a judicial clerk for Judge Patti Henning, 17th Judicial Circuit of Florida, Fort Lauderdale. He is a member of the Palm Beach County Bar Association. Mr. Steinbaum concentrates his practice in the area of PIP Suit Litigation.

Tara L. Kopp, Esq. is admitted to the Florida Bar. She earned a Bachelor's Degree from Palm Beach Atlantic University, West Palm Beach, Florida. She earned her law degree from Nova Southeastern University Shepard Broad Law Center in Fort Lauderdale, Florida. Ms. Kopp received a Silver Pro Bono Honors Recognition while obtaining her Juris Doctorate at Shepard Broad Law Center. She had the distinct honor of interning for Judge Peter Evans in West Palm Beach. Ms. Kopp is a member of the American Bar Association and a member of the Palm Beach County Bar Association. Ms. Kopp takes prides in being a successful and aggressive attorney, and giving back to her community through service. She concentrates her practice in the area of PIP Suit Litigation.

 

Professionals of the Firm 

Marvin Pincus, JD is a Senior Case Manager in the Personal Injury Division. He earned a Bachelors of Arts from City University in New York in 1961. He earned a Juris Doctor from St. Johns University School of Law in 1967. He was admitted to the New Jersey Bar in 1968. Mr. Pincus has been an attorney for over 30 years and served as a senior trial attorney in New Jersey, specializing in litigation in the areas of personal injury, workers compensation, medical malpractice, workplace safety, product liability and premises liability. He served on the Board of Governors for the New Jersey Association of Trial Lawyers and served as President of The New Jersey Association for Trial Lawyers for over 10 years. He is a certified Civil Trial Attorney in the state of New Jersey. Mr. Pincus is a member of the Million Dollar Advocates Forum, based on his outstanding results for his clients. He has lectured extensively on numerous topics, including products liability, no-fault auto insurance, and medical malpractice. His legal efforts have resulted in several published cases involving legal precedents, including Mercado v. Transport of New Jersey, Mott v. Callahan AMS Machine Company and Palamone v. Patterson Board of Education. Mr. Pincus is a member of the American Association of Justice, Association of Trial Lawyers of America – New Jersey. * - Licensed to practice in New Jersey 

Paul D. Baltrun  is the Director of the Loss Mitigation Division. He has over 15 years of experience in the mortgage and loss mitigation industry. In addition to having built and developed multiple mortgage-related companies, Mr. Baltrun also has extensive experience in operational and upper-level management. He possesses a vast knowledge of the mortgage industry, and continues to utilize his skills to help clients achieve positive outcomes in their mortgage-related matters. In addition to his mortgage industry experience, Mr. Baltrun has also worked in the fields of secondary marketing and real estate trusts. His accomplishments include being a member of an elite management team designed by a Fortune 500 CEO, and serving as president of a company licensed as a correspondent mortgage lender.